How Can the U.S. Solve the Immigration Crisis? We Asked ChatGPT

The TV debate between Vice President Kamala Harris and former president Donald Trump saw the two question one another’s character and trade barbs in a lively encounter that gave both an opportunity to address the nation’s biggest concerns.

Few issues concern American voters more than immigration and none seem to invoke the kind of highly-charged atmosphere that characterizes discussion of the border and who has the right to live here.

This rising desire for tighter immigration controls is now bipartisan: a recent Gallup poll showed a 15-point surge among Republicans, an 11-point increase among independents and a 10-point increase among Democrats compared to a year ago.

But as Trump promises to carry out mass deportations of unlawful migrants and Harris pledges to revive President Joe Biden‘s failed bipartisan border security bill, the problem appears ever more intractable and both Democrats and Republicans are searching for answers.

Newsweek recruited the generative AI tool, ChatGPT, to see if it could help the presidential hopefuls.

We asked it: “How Can the U.S. Solve the Immigration Crisis? Give reasons for your answers and provide policy solutions.”

ChatGPT came up with 10 policy ideas to solve the U.S.-Mexico border crisis, summarizing the issue as follows: “The U.S. immigration crisis is complex, driven by factors like economic inequality, political instability in neighboring countries, labor demands, and flaws in the U.S. immigration system itself. Solving this issue requires a multi-faceted approach that balances humanitarian concerns, economic needs, and national security. Below are several policy solutions, along with reasons for each.”

Comprehensive Immigration Reform

• Policy: Overhaul the immigration system to streamline legal immigration processes, address backlogs, and create clear pathways for different categories of immigrants, including skilled workers, family members, and refugees.
• Reason: The current system is outdated, inefficient, and does not align with modern economic and humanitarian needs. Reducing bureaucratic delays will prevent people from resorting to illegal methods of entry and better match labor demands with available workers.

Enhanced Border Security Paired with Smart Immigration Policies

• Policy: Increase funding for technology-based solutions at the border (drones, surveillance, electronic monitoring) instead of focusing solely on physical barriers. Simultaneously, enhance security cooperation with countries of origin to prevent dangerous migration journeys.
• Reason: Securing the border is necessary to manage illegal immigration and human trafficking, but doing so with a smart approach can avoid militarizing the border or creating humanitarian crises. High-tech solutions are less invasive and more efficient than building walls.

Pathway to Legalization for Undocumented Immigrants

• Policy: Create a clear, conditional pathway to legalization for the estimated 11 million undocumented immigrants already in the U.S., provided they meet specific criteria (such as background checks, proof of contribution through work or taxes, and learning English).
• Reason: Many undocumented immigrants are already integrated into American communities and contribute to the economy. Offering them legal status would stabilize their lives, improve public safety, and increase tax revenues.

Revamping the Asylum System

• Policy: Reform the asylum process to make it faster and more efficient, while ensuring that claims are processed fairly and humanely. Partner with countries of origin to create regional processing centers that assess asylum claims before individuals reach the U.S. border.
• Reason: The current asylum system is overwhelmed, leading to long delays and encouraging people to make dangerous journeys to the U.S. Providing regional processing options will decrease illegal crossings and protect those genuinely fleeing persecution.

Investment in Central American Development

• Policy: Increase U.S. foreign aid and diplomatic efforts to improve economic conditions, governance, and security in Central American countries, such as El Salvador, Honduras, and Guatemala.
• Reason: A large portion of migrants come from countries facing poverty, violence, and political instability. By addressing root causes through aid and development programs, the U.S. can reduce the pressure of migration at its southern border.

Temporary Worker Programs

• Policy: Expand and simplify temporary work visa programs for sectors like agriculture, construction, and hospitality that rely heavily on migrant labor. Include safeguards to prevent exploitation and abuse of migrant workers.
• Reason: The U.S. economy relies on immigrant labor, particularly for low-wage jobs that Americans are often unwilling to do. Providing legal avenues for temporary work can meet labor demands while discouraging illegal immigration.

Faster processing for highly skilled immigrants

• Policy: Prioritize the admission and processing of highly skilled immigrants by increasing visa availability for tech workers, scientists, and other professionals. Reform the H-1B visa process to prevent abuse and ensure it benefits both U.S. companies and workers.
• Reason: The U.S. faces a shortage of highly skilled workers in industries critical for economic growth. Attracting talent from abroad strengthens the economy and helps maintain America’s competitive edge in global markets.

Addressing the Status of DACA Recipients (Dreamers)

• Policy: Provide permanent legal status to individuals under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program who were brought to the U.S. as children and offer them a pathway to citizenship.
• Reason: Dreamers have grown up in the U.S. and often know no other country. Many contribute significantly to the economy and society. Offering them stability through legal status is both compassionate and pragmatic.

Streamlining Family Reunification

• Policy: Revise family-based immigration categories to reduce long wait times and backlogs, especially for spouses, children, and parents of U.S. citizens and permanent residents.

• Reason: Long waits for family reunification encourage illegal immigration and create hardship for immigrant families. Streamlining the process supports the family unit, which is a foundational value in U.S. society.

Public-private Partnerships for Immigration Integration

• Policy: Encourage partnerships between government, businesses, and nonprofits to facilitate the integration of immigrants through language learning, job training, and community-building programs.

• Reason: Effective integration helps immigrants contribute more fully to society and the economy. It also reduces social tensions and increases the likelihood of long-term success for immigrant communities.

“Addressing the immigration crisis requires balancing enforcement with compassion and long-term solutions. By improving legal immigration channels, enhancing border security, addressing root causes of migration, and offering paths to legalization for those already in the U.S., the country can better manage immigration while upholding its values of opportunity and inclusion. Solving this crisis will involve cooperation across political lines as well as collaboration with international partners,” Chatgpt said.

ChatGPT remarks align with the comments recently made by GOP lawmaker Tony Gonzelez, who called for Republicans and Democrats to join forces to come to a bipartisan agreement on immigration and border security.

“I will work with anyone that wants to truly solve this problem,” he said.

Democrats accused Republicans of tanking the bipartisan border security bill on the orders of Trump.

The GOP claims Democrats are unwilling to work with them to solve the crisis.

Do you have a story Newsweek should be covering? Do you have any questions about this story? Contact LiveNews@newsweek.com.